Returns: How to Read a Store's Policy Before You Buy

Rewritten in 2026. The original, published in 2017, listed named retailers and their policies. That list is no longer usable — policies have tightened across the industry, return fees have become common, and several of the named chains no longer exist.

The return policy is the part of a purchase nobody reads until it matters, and it has changed more in the last few years than in the previous twenty.

Rather than a list of stores that will be wrong within a season, here is how to read a policy and what to check before buying — particularly for a gift.

What changed

Free returns stopped being universal. A large number of retailers now deduct a return shipping fee or a restocking charge from the refund, including some that previously did not.

Windows shortened. Thirty days is now common where ninety used to be, and holiday extensions are narrower than they were.

Receipt requirements tightened. Returns without a receipt increasingly get store credit at the lowest recent price, if they are accepted at all.

Return tracking arrived. Several major retailers now track return behaviour across purchases, and customers who return frequently can be refused.

Online and in-store diverged. An item bought online may not be returnable in a shop, and vice versa. This catches people constantly.

What the law actually requires

Worth knowing, because it is less than most people assume.

There is no general federal right to return an item you simply changed your mind about. Return policies are set by the retailer, and a "no returns" policy is lawful provided it is disclosed.

Faulty goods are different. Items that are defective or not as described are covered by warranty law, which is separate from the return policy and cannot be waived by a sign at the counter.

Some states require disclosure. A number of states require retailers to post their return policy conspicuously, and where they fail to, a default period may apply. This varies and is worth knowing for your own state.

Credit card protections sit on top. If a retailer will not resolve a genuine problem, the card issuer's dispute process is the route — and it is stronger than most people realise. See buying online.

What to check before buying a gift

Two minutes, and it prevents the awkward conversation in January.

The window, and when it starts. Purchase date or delivery date. For a gift bought in November, a thirty-day window from purchase has expired before it is opened.

Whether there is a holiday extension, and what its actual end date is.

Whether a gift receipt exists, and get one. It allows a return without revealing the price.

Who pays for return shipping, if it was bought online.

Whether there is a restocking fee, particularly on electronics.

Whether it can be returned in a shop if bought online.

Whether the category is excluded. Opened electronics, personalised items, seasonal goods, and anything perishable are commonly non-returnable regardless of the general policy.

Practical habits

Keep the receipt with the gift, not in your own file. A gift receipt tucked into the box costs nothing.

Photograph receipts. Thermal paper fades to blank within months, and a photograph is accepted by most retailers.

Check the policy on the day you buy, not the day you return. Policies change, and the terms at purchase are what apply.

Do not remove packaging you might need. Many policies require the original box.

Return promptly. Windows are shorter than they were, and nothing improves by waiting.

Ask, even outside the window. Policies are minimums, and staff frequently have discretion. Politeness works.

If a return is refused unfairly

Ask for the policy in writing and check it against what you were told at purchase.

Escalate to the retailer's customer service, not the shop floor.

If the item is faulty, say so explicitly — that is a warranty matter, not a return, and the rules are different.

Use the card issuer's dispute process if the retailer will not resolve it. There are time limits, so do this promptly rather than after months of correspondence.

Your state consumer protection office handles disclosure failures.

The one habit worth adopting

Ask about the return policy at the counter, before paying, for anything that is a gift.

It takes ten seconds, it is a completely ordinary question, and it is the difference between a present that can be exchanged and one that becomes a problem for the person who received it.

Rewritten in 2026. The original listed 2017 policies for named retailers, cited a 2017 National Retail Federation survey, and predated the widespread introduction of return fees and return tracking.

For additional public information on everyday cybersecurity, see Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency.